Los­ing my Code­pen­dent Church Self

St Johns Bridge, Port­land, Ore­gon (photo by Pam Hogeweide)

I live in a city of bridges. Thir­teen bridges in all that con­nect the east side of Port­land to the west side of the Willamette River.   I like the bridges in Portland.There is the Fre­mont Bridge, the Sell­wood Bridge, the Hawthorne Bridge, the Mor­ri­son and the Steel Bridge, a unique bridge that raises up it’s cen­ter part when large water ves­sels need to pass under.  My favorite bridge, though, is the St John’s Bridge, which hap­pens to be about a mile from my house.

A few years ago the St John’s Bridge was spruced up with some updates and a fresh coat of paint. To cel­e­brate the debut of the newly gus­si­fied bridge, the neigh­bor­hood threw a street party and closed the bridge for a while so folks could throng to it by foot, bike and skate­board. My daugh­ter and I were there. We trot­ted with the rest of the neigh­bor­hood down the mid­dle of the bridge, rel­ish­ing what we knew was likely the only time we’d ever be able to do this. When we reached the top of the slope, we paused to look over the rail at the river far down below.

On one side of the bridge we viewed the cityscape of Port­land with water­craft motor­ing to and fro around the river.  We crossed the road­way to the other side and viewed the indus­tri­al­ized areas of the busy river ports below.  So dif­fer­ent from one side to the other. It was like look­ing at two  entirely dif­fer­ent rivers.

My rela­tion­ship with the body of Christ is so much like this bridge. For many years I hov­ered in the busy waters of church vol­un­teerism spend­ing a great deal of time and energy in ser­vice. I felt that this kind of serv­ing was for a higher pur­pose, for I was serv­ing the king­dom of God, right?  At one point, I became dis­mayed as I looked at my cal­en­dar and real­ized how many things I was tied into that were church-​​centered. My faith com­mu­nity at that time had many oppor­tu­ni­ties to serve and I jumped in on just about any­thing I could. I was at my church on aver­age three nights a week plus most of Sun­day. All of my social­iz­ing became church-​​centered, too. Star­ing at my kitchen cal­en­dar that day could have been the tip-​​off that I needed to scale back. But I ignored the facts star­ing me in the face and pushed aside my uneasi­ness with hav­ing built such a church-​​drenched exis­tence for myself and my family.

One morn­ing in a time of prayer–with all those min­istries I helped with I had to keep the prayer tank filled–I heard that famil­iar  small Voice that rings big inside when I’m pay­ing attention:

Unplug from every min­istry you are in. 

These six words flooded my soul like a spot­light in a prison yard. In an instant I was filled with an aware­ness of how hard I was work­ing for the love of God. Rev­e­la­tion and wis­dom cov­ered me right then and there with her heal­ing power unleash­ing within me.

I love you no mat­ter what. If you never do noth­ing for Me again,  you are loved.

I am going to prove this to you. Sit down and do nothing.

Tears welled up inside and out. I had no idea that in all of my zeal to serve and over­serve, that I had been oper­at­ing under the tyranny of being per­for­mance dri­ven to earn God’s love.  I was undone.

And so, over the com­ing weeks I did just that, I began pulling the plug on the var­i­ous min­istries I had bus­ied my life with. I gave notice to the children’s pas­tor from teach­ing Sun­day school and  lead­ing the children’s mis­sions pro­gram;  I noti­fied  the pas­tor for the prayer coun­sel­ing min­istry and prophetic team that I was pulling out, and I resigned myself from the early morn­ing prayer meet­ings and pre-​​service prayer times that I had been attend­ing. Yeah. I was a prayer superstar.

All of the lead­ers were gra­cious and affirm­ing. “We all need time to rest our souls,” they said.

Thus, I began a new jour­ney into being a Christ fol­lower who Does Noth­ing. 

It was alright at first, but within a few weeks I began to real­ize two things:  I was more secure in the love of God than I had real­ized.  I knew with all my bones and mar­row that I was among the beloved…no mat­ter what. I knew with every­thing inside of me that I could not ever be a pro­duc­tive daugh­ter in the king­dom of God again and that the Almighty was just fine with that. “I love you no mat­ter what,” soared like a ban­ner across my life. I was content.

The sec­ond thing that I real­ized was dis­con­cert­ing.  I began to see that I was unno­tice­able among my church com­mu­nity when I was not Doing Min­istry.  My phone stopped ring­ing. My cal­en­dar was a ghost town and my social engage­ments shriv­eled up as if I had moved out of town.  What the…?

One Sun­day one of the min­istry lead­ers approached me. A lit­tle hope surged inside of me that per­haps I wasn’t so forgotten.

Pam, how are you?”

Fine, thanks, and you?”

I’m good. So when are you com­ing back to the prayer team?  I need people.”

I don’t know.”

Well let me know when you do know. I need people.”

Are you tired? Worn out? Burned out on reli­gion? Come to me. Get away with me and you’ll recover your life. I’ll show you how to take a real rest. Walk with me and work with me — watch how I do it. Learn the unforced rhythms of grace. I won’t lay any­thing heavy or ill-​​fitting on you. Keep com­pany with me and you’ll learn to live freely and lightly. - Matt. 11:28 (MSG)

And with that, she walked away. I sat there a bit stunned. The view was get­ting clearer. My place in this faith com­mu­nity seemed to loom on Doing rather than Being.  I was deter­mined to  stay out of the matrix though, and really, there was no temp­ta­tion to back­slide pre­ma­turely into min­istry of any kind.

Over the next months, two other pas­tors approached me, attempt­ing to recruit me to their min­istry areas. One of them offered me a job. Are you seri­ous?  For years I had yearned to be on church staff, think­ing it would be amaz­ing to earn a salary and be truly involved in a voca­tional capac­ity.  It was a dream of mine, a small dream, but a dream just the same. As he offered me a job to be his assis­tant, I leaned my spirit in towards my Father in heaven, silently ask­ing for guid­ance.   Noth­ing. Not a word. Not a hint, not a clue.

Yet some­how I knew that I could not yet come out of my spir­i­tual rest. With con­fi­dence and total peace I politely turned down his offer.

As time passed,  my rela­tion­ships with folks in this com­mu­nity became weaker. Pas­tors no longer called me to con­sult with me about their vision;  women did not return my calls and Sun­day meet­ings at church began to feel emp­tier and emp­tier.  It was bewil­der­ing and dis­tress­ing. I loved church! I loved the peo­ple!  What was hap­pen­ing that I now found excuses to skip church?  What was going on?

It finally came to me.  My soul wilder­ness, as I had come to define this sea­son of bar­ren­ness, revealed how secure my rela­tion­ship with God was, but it also revealed how inse­cure my rela­tion­ship with the peo­ple of God had become.  As I jour­neyed on this bridge from being a work­horse for Jesus to becom­ing just a sim­ple, inac­tive pew warmer,  my view of myself in the body of Christ became crys­tal clear.  It was true I per­formed to be accepted and loved… but that per­for­mance was not really for my Cre­ator. It was for his cre­ated. In my search to belong and be accepted, I had been will­ing to do what it takes to be amongst the tribe of the church. And the pri­mary way one becomes Amongst is to Plug In.

Over time, I have come to real­ize how code­pen­dent I have been with every sin­gle church I have ever been a part of. Every sin­gle one. My bro­ken, dam­aged wom­anly soul needs to belong. When I serve, vol­un­teer, show up, work, over­work, pray and over pray, I Am In.

When I unplugged, I was forgotten.

It’s been sev­eral years now since I crossed the road from my busy indus­tri­al­ized reli­gious life. I’ve been stand­ing at the rail for a long while, soak­ing up this new view with a mix­ture of lib­erty, lone­li­ness and grief.  Though my accep­tance had been con­di­tional, it was, after all, accep­tance. My phone rang. My cal­en­dar was a mash-​​up of Chris­t­ian chaos.  I was sought after and affirmed for my spir­i­tual giftings.

Now, like a way­farer on a lonely bridge, I am tak­ing my time to recover who I am apart from the machine of min­istry. It’s a painful process. My iden­tity was so tan­gled up with reli­gious activ­ity.  And it was good activ­ity.  I’ve prayed with the broken-​​hearted, served the poor, cooked for home­less cit­i­zens and gave Sun­day school lessons to the next gen­er­a­tion. I’ve given money, time, energy and tal­ent to the tribe that I des­per­ately wanted to just love me for who I am and not what I can offer.  But like an imma­ture boyfriend who dumps you after you stop putting out,  I was left alone with no prom date.  I don’t like this, yet I am mak­ing amends with myself about it. I’m learn­ing to Not be Amongst the very tribe that was my life for most of my adult life.

The view from here is not so bad. I can see more of the river with­out the hub­bub of port activ­ity clut­ter­ing up the water­way. The blue sky blazes down from the Ore­gon sky. Port­land shines in who she is,  her thir­teen bridges criss­cross­ing east to west.  I respect those who do the work of min­istry and suc­ceed at it.  I am not one of them. I am just me with my empty cal­en­dar and quiet telephone.

*****

Spe­cial shout-​​out to She Loves mag­a­zine and the arti­cle,  Learn­ing the Unforced Rhythms of Grace that helped prompt today’s blog post. Def­i­nitely worth tak­ing a moment to link up and read.

Did this post res­onate with you? Pass it on!

Comments

Los­ing my Code­pen­dent Church Self — 21 Comments

  1. Pingback: serve until it hurts « papyrus will grow

    • @LaVonne, so good and encour­ag­ing. Had you been a part of your faith com­mu­nity for long? I know how hard a deci­sion that can be if there are years and years of his­tory with a spe­cific church. It is almost like a divorce. But it is a nec­es­sary break, in my opin­ion, if a woman’s soul is being sti­fled and worse, her chil­dren are being raised to con­tinue under the “polite oppres­sion” of com­ple­men­tar­ian Chris­tian­ity. So let me HIGH FIVE you and THANK YOU for break­ing rank with the sta­tus quo. There is a grow­ing com­pany of women who are find­ing lib­erty and God’s good pres­ence out­side the con­fines of those struc­tures that tell us to mind our place. You inspire me!!

  2. First, you are a gifted writer. I’m new to your site. Found you via Chris­tian­ity Today. I love find­ing new blogs and new per­spec­tives, and yours has been a breath of fresh air.

    This is a tough sub­ject because we know that faith and works go together and work­ing in min­istry with fel­low Chris­tians is part of the fel­low­ship of the Church, yet we can go way too far past the point of no return in min­istry. I’ve done so at the expense of fam­ily. They sur­vived my crazy sea­son, but God lit­er­ally moved our fam­ily and closed doors to all min­istry so I now have time to write. I grieved for a few months, but I knew His plans are bet­ter than mine, and I was tired. I’m learn­ing that God has pur­poses for us each day and dreams for each sea­son. I’m learn­ing that my call may be to a neigh­bor or a nation. I sim­ply must obey for today.

    I think what I appre­ci­ated the most about your post was your obe­di­ence to God’s voice. I know that He has even more for you in this sea­son of “still­ness” than what you’ve dis­cov­ered so far. Maybe another book!

    Bless­ings!
    andy

  3. I wish I had the courage to send this to a few peo­ple. You see, I just stepped out of the “mash up of Chris­t­ian chaos.” My whole life has revolved around the church — the same church to be exact. My iden­tity was so wrapped up in my home church I knew that if I was ever going to get to know the real me, I would have to leave. So I finally did it. After a life­time (lit­er­ally) of atten­dance and 22 years as a staff pas­tor, I quit. I had a good excuse (as if I needed one), my husband’s job required a two hour com­mute, so we’re moving.

    Here’s the scary part for me — I don’t miss “church.” I don’t have any desire to jump back into that chaos. I’m an ordained min­is­ter for cry­ing out loud. I’m fin­ish­ing a Master’s Degree in min­istry lead­er­ship and I have no desire to serve on a church staff. When I started this Master’s pro­gram at age 53, I cer­tainly didn’t see this coming.

    For­tu­nately (and I think this is just my per­son­al­ity) I have main­tained some won­der­ful friend­ships. I’ve dis­cov­ered that peo­ple didn’t just want to be around me because I was a pas­tor and could offer them some spir­i­tual com­mod­ity or ser­vice. I still have real com­mu­nity and I’m so grate­ful for that.

    At the same time, I’m just a lit­tle dis­turbed at this lack of desire for church. I think my hus­band is a lit­tle wor­ried about me. He calls skip­ping church on Sun­day a bad habit. Maybe some­day I’ll jump back into the main­stream of church atten­dance and involve­ment. But not now. For now I’m just enjoy­ing the breath­ing room. I hope if I ever do take another stab at “church” life, I can carry that with me.

    • Vickie!
      Thanks so much for telling some of your story. I know that you are not alone in this and I hope you know that too!

      There are SO MANY peo­ple who are expe­ri­enc­ing exactly what you describe. Some would even say it’s an epi­demic occur­ring across the body of Christ, at least in Amer­ica, though I know it is not con­fined to the States. There is a “holy dis­con­tent­ment” gust­ing up around the global col­lec­tive of Jesus followers.

      I know a num­ber of ex-​​church pas­tors who have found cre­ative, new ways to pas­tor and teach in the gift­ing and pas­sion that is in them. We don’t have to be in the Insti­tu­tional Church to Do Church or Fol­low Jesus. I trust that you know that.…and hope that your hus­band will dis­cover that!

      Bless­ings and wis­dom to you as you con­tinue on your jour­ney of faith. So good to hear that you have a com­mu­nity of friends around you. Com­pan­ion­ship has been such a life­saver for me as my rela­tion­ship with the Church has changed so much over the past seven years. My friends have been light­houses for me as I trek through new ter­ri­tory of becom­ing a Church­less Jesus Woman.…though in the fall I think we’ll be invit­ing folks to come join us a cou­ple times a month for a spir­i­tual gath­er­ing of the mis­fits and dis­en­fran­chised. There are many, many like us!

      Keep us posted on how it goes for you, and be sure to check out my friend’ blog, http://​www​.kathyesco​bar​.com I think her writ­ing will res­onate with you!

  4. The Clergy Project, a pri­vate, invitation-​​only “safe house” com­mu­nity of cur­rent and for­mer ministers .

    http://​www​.recov​er​ingfrom​re​li​gion​.org/​p​a​g​e​s​/​J​e​r​r​y​D​e​W​itt

    Jer­ry­De­Witt .… more than twenty-​​five years of Pen­te­costal min­istry in his home state of Louisiana. His min­istry expe­ri­ence begin at the early age of sev­en­teen and included evan­ge­liz­ing across the United States and being the assis­tant pas­tor of two United Pen­te­costal churches as well as one Apos­tolic church. Dur­ing his dilemma with doubt Jerry ulti­mately held the senior pas­torate of two very unique con­gre­ga­tions, one charis­matic domin­ion­ist and the other non-​​denominational fundamentalist.

  5. Beau­ti­ful, Pam … Such an impor­tant per­spec­tive … I wish every min­istry leader could read this.

    Those words: “Unplug from every min­istry you are in.” Whew.

    And these ones: “I love you no mat­ter what. If you never do noth­ing for Me again, you are loved.

    I am going to prove this to you. Sit down and do noth­ing.” I’ve heard God say some­thing sim­i­lar to me … I have to test my heart reg­u­larly that I don’t DO, instead of BE. I am in a very busy sea­son of “doing” and “build­ing.” I think this whole theme of “Rest” is part of fig­ur­ing out just how much to do and much to just be … find­ing that beau­ti­ful Grace in between. I am “learning” – as Helen put it so beau­ti­fully today. So so much to learn. Your post is part of this learn­ing, for sure.

    • Hi Idelette,
      SheLoves mag is becom­ing quiet an influ­ence in my blog­ging lately, thanks to your keen edi­to­r­ial leadership!

      Thanks so much for read­ing and commenting…and quot­ing! Love how you pull out quotes that specif­i­cally caught your eye.

      I am about to announce a blog sab­bat­i­cal for myself in a week or so. Tak­ing a rest from some­thing I enjoy and am try­ing to keep build­ing momen­tum for takes a bit of courage and trust. Will read­ers for­get me if I don’t blog for four weeks? I know the answer to that, yet I also know that rest and dis­en­gag­ing is so ben­e­fi­cial for not only the soul but also the cre­ative process.

      Yet a break is dif­fer­ent from dis­en­gag­ing and though I did not real­ize it at the time, I was def­i­nitely dis­en­gag­ing from a hyper reli­gious life. And once I got untan­gled, I began to build a spir­i­tual life. I have so much more to process and say about this. I will def be explor­ing this at length in my upcom­ing book project. Excited about it!!

  6. I spent a lot of post-​​college time and energy at my home church serv­ing as Chris­t­ian Edu­ca­tion Direc­tor, Sun­day school teacher, Vaca­tion Bible School teacher, Youth Fel­low­ship leader…and I loved it. I felt needed, I felt use­ful, and I felt loved by most of the peo­ple. I sup­pose you could say that I felt loved and approved of by God too. I loved what I was doing so much that I went to sem­i­nary so I could do this for a liv­ing.
    Well, fast for­ward to when I got mar­ried and trans­ferred to my husband’s church in a dif­fer­ent denom­i­na­tion. In that church, I got the mes­sage that it was expected for every per­son in reg­u­lar atten­dance to serve in some capac­ity. I spent the next almost 10 years try­ing to “break in” to the teach­ing min­istry there. I became active in a num­ber of other areas, I guess to feel use­ful and to fill that void. When I finally was given a class to teach, some­thing hap­pened that hurt me very deeply, and we ended up pulling out of that church, with me vow­ing never to serve in or trust a church again. Some of what really hurt dur­ing that time was that when we left, it seemed that no one really noticed or cared. Out of a church of maybe 3000, only 2 or 3 ever called to ask what hap­pened or how we were doing. One per­son even called to gar­ner sup­port for some change in min­istry, some­one I had talked to a lot and had been in a Sun­day school class with me. This per­son hadn’t even real­ized that our fam­ily had not been there for half a year. It was like I wasn’t val­ued as a per­son, only as a body to fill a void in a min­istry.
    A friend who had also left that church, for other rea­sons, got me through the worst of that time, and she told me that maybe this was a sea­son for me to just step back from min­istry and “sit in God’s lap and be His lit­tle girl for a while.” A beau­ti­ful image, to be sure, but how could God love me if I wasn’t doing any­thing for Him? The churches I have attended since get­ting mar­ried all stress that to be a mem­ber of a church is to take an active part in some form of min­is­ter­ing to oth­ers. One pas­tor I’ve heard dur­ing this time even said, “If you’re here to just sit and be fed, you might want to go some­where else, because we want our mem­bers to be active.” I get his point of view, but at the same time, I feel that peo­ple are being guilted into serv­ing. Did Jesus do that to gain fol­low­ers?
    That year and a half was very hard for me, as I strug­gled with a sense that I was wast­ing my sem­i­nary degree, wast­ing my life, and fail­ing God. I turned down paid min­istry oppor­tu­ni­ties because some­thing didn’t feel right, and I strug­gled because I won­dered if I was just mak­ing excuses.
    Well, I have come full cir­cle, and we are at a church where I feel wel­comed and loved, and I am begin­ning to get involved in min­istry again. I still have no one who calls me just to hang out or talk or do some­thing fun. I still won­der some­times if I’m doing enough with the church, and I feel guilty when I see places where peo­ple are needed. And I still won­der some days if I’m doing min­istry to please God or to be accepted by the pow­ers that be in the church, or am I still try­ing to earn what God has already freely given me?

    • Oh Deb how my heart feels for you. There is so much here…

      One pas­tor I’ve heard dur­ing this time even said, “If you’re here to just sit and be fed, you might want to go some­where else, because we want our mem­bers to be active.” I get his point of view, but at the same time, I feel that peo­ple are being guilted into serv­ing. Did Jesus do that to gain fol­low­ers?
      I have heard (and even pro­moted!!!) this per­spec­tive many times. Get plugged in, is the mantra I usu­ally heard. There is a ten­sion there, for of course com­mu­nity and rela­tion­ships are built by spend­ing time together and of course to have a friend we have to be a friend.…yet, there is some­thing dis­con­cert­ing about putting our time, tal­ents and energy into an entity that often treats us like employ­ees rather than fam­ily. This is some­thing I have been reflect­ing on for years. Years.
      Why do we have expec­ta­tions for our faith com­mu­ni­ties to accept us and love us and nur­ture us when we do not have this expec­ta­tion for most other cir­cles we run in, like work, school, or other organizations?

      I think a large part of it is that churches that are program-​​heavy need bod­ies to run those pro­grams and it becomes about our pres­ence being nec­es­sary to run the show rather than being present to Just Be Present. I def­i­nitely felt used after I exited the matrix and began to process on my years of hyper-​​religious ser­vice. My code­pen­dent ten­den­cies were fer­tile ground for me to get roped into doing all kinds of min­istry activ­ity that really I ought not to have been doing, espe­cially when I had small children.

      My friend Kathy Esco­bar has a great class she has devel­oped called The Walk­ing Wounded. It’s a four week course that helps Chris­tians or for­mer Chris­tians go through a guided series of ques­tions and reflec­tions about the hurt they’ve incurred from The Church. I signed up for it in Feb. It was so help­ful in giv­ing me some insight into why I was so affected by my church expe­ri­ences. Next time she offers it I will be sure to post a shout-​​out!

      (hug) to you Deb. Let us keep jour­ney­ing together in the love and grace of our Creator!

    • Deb,
      If you were nearby, I’d call you to hang out, talk or do some­thing fun! Your story is very sim­i­lar to mine (scary sim­i­lar) even down to the year and a half of rest­ing in noth­ing­ness. Bless you as you con­tinue to process your past and pro­ceed in your jour­ney with whole­ness, con­fi­dence and trust in Christ and your inner Voice.

      • Aw, thanks! That’s always nice to hear, espe­cially when it seem there are so few peo­ple around here that I con­nect with on a lot of these issues. It really feels alone when it seems that every­one else “fits in” and is con­tent with who they are and what oth­ers expect of them.

  7. Beau­ti­ful, Pam. Such an impor­tant insight and expe­ri­ence. For me, unplug­ging is becom­ing a part of my life rhythm every so many years. It recon­nects me to humil­ity (the church does just fine with­out me), rest (exposes hid­den stress), bal­ance (reminds me of pri­or­i­ties I for­got and self care) and mar­gins (I want to be avail­able to oth­ers at the drop of a dime). Love the anal­ogy of the St. John’s Bridge. Jon was just there play­ing his cello for a wed­ding in Cathe­dral Park last night.

    • Har­riet!! How cool that John was just at Cathe­dral Park under the St Johns bridge. Such a scenic park!

      Love how you framed it:
      It recon­nects me to humil­ity (the church does just fine with­out me), rest (exposes hid­den stress), bal­ance (reminds me of pri­or­i­ties I for­got and self care) and mar­gins (I want to be avail­able to oth­ers at the drop of a dime).

      Humility…yep. There is a lot to talk about right there that folks can get by just fine with­out me there tak­ing care of what­ever min­istry I am involved with. Life goes on With­out Me…imagine!!!

      You and I are over­due for some hang­out time!!! I think I have your num­ber. I’m off this Thur and Fri. Maybe a cof­fee date??