Creative. Typically used as a descriptive word, such as, “She is such a creative home decorator.” More and more, though, creative is being used as a noun, as in Creative: “There is a rising Creative class.”
And then there’s author John O’Keefe, who heralds Creatives in his new book, The Church Creative. A great read that envisions a 21st century spiritual revolution with Creatives agitating the collective imagination.
Creatives are those people who see things differently than the rest of us. They are futuristic, or possibilitarians as Portland artist, Kelly Rae Roberts describes her creative self. Traditionalists and Creatives don’t get along so good, as you can imagine. The traditionalist bemoans, “We are watering down our practices,” the Creative declares, “Time to rethink what we know.” It is the courage of the Creatives that leads us to the changes that we need.
It is the What ifs that moved us from the rotary phone, to the push button phone, to the cordless phone, to the cell phone, to the smart phone, and it is the What ifs that will bring about the next evolution of communication. The What ifs questions should be the questions that move us forward, that move us to explore and grow. But it depends on how we answer the What ifs. When we’re confronted with the question, “What if we change?” We usually answer that question in the negative. What I’ve found is that Creatives answer the What ifs in the positive. — The Church Creative
I love this. But I want to pause here and qualify something : when we speak of Church please note that church is whatever one makes of it. Church is a corporate gathering of Christ followers and seekers who meet together in a building; church is a gathering that meets up in a living room or outside in a forest; church is Sunday dinner with table fellowship among friends and family. Church is people doing life together.
When we’re walking in the light of the Divine we’re called to re-imagine the possibilities. To re-imagine the idea of how we’re called to do what we do. Come on, admit it — you thought the easiest way was to send the servant to buy more wine, but Jesus took the opportunity to say, “Rethink the possible and ask What If?” The Church Creative
As we approach the second decade of the 21st century, things in the institutional form of church are rockin’ and rollin’. I cannot count how many dissatisfied-disillusioned-discontent-dissident Christians I’ve spoken with in the last eight years. There is an epidemic of church refugees. This sounds bad. But in this grand exodus the Creatives are emerging with banners boldly blazing the What If’s. Creatives are pushing through the wilderness of doubt and cynicism to explore new ways of Being Church with one another. Creatives are our prophets, our holy men and women who dare to throw off the old and soar into the wild, unknown new. Their What If spirit says, “Let’s go!”
Creatives bring to life some amazing things and the most exciting is this ability to re-imagine the gathering of followers they serve. For Creatives, nothing is off limits when it comes to re-imaging possibilities. Creatives are always asking What if, because they’re curious and because they see things very differently; most of the time they see things better. The Church Creative
I love this. Creatives may agitate and challenge the status quo, but it’s from a posture of hopeful expectancy. This is much needed in our jaded, over-marketed, scandalized modern times. We need our Creatives to revive our childlike wonder with playful What If’s. It’s that creative daring that will allow us freedom to experiment, to explore, to fail and to try again.
Author and blogger, Jennifer Luitwieler, recounted on her blog today a message she recently heard from a Creative who had this to say to the Church:
Making art is hard and painful. When things go wrong in creativity, they can actually be going right. from Jennifer’s blog
I want to apply this sentiment to the Church we find ourselves in (or exiting as is the case for so many of us!) — Creating church is hard and painful. When things go wrong in church, they can actually be going right.
So here’s the question: What if Creatives were unleashed to make church new? How does that look? Are you seeing that anywhere in your sphere of life right now? Are you a Creative?


“Creatives may agitate and challenge the status quo, but it’s from a posture of hopeful expectancy.” –That spoke to me in a wild way! Every church I went to I would almost always GET IN TROUBLE! Why? Because I would analyze the way folks did things in their ministries and then prompt change. The main question or filter in my mind would be, “Is this helping or hurting people?” Many times I would end up being the leader in children’s ministry, bible studies, teaching in prisons or rehabs and I could not do it the way the original person did and I would change it because I wanted to see people touched by God. God would be the originator of the ideas and I would institute them. Man, I got so much crap from pastors, elders and leaders in the church! I tired of being treated like I was a novice when I was following what God would show me but because I was honest about my shortcomings, they would use anything I shared against me. I learned quickly that church was NOT a safe place to share honestly. So, God has me OUTSIDE the church to reach others (as you know). We have been blessed at the rehab that I teach at. I can be honest, funny and be myself. We are seeing honesty being cultivated in the clients in the rehab. It’s so great when the guys feel safe to share their hearts with us. Pam, thank you for your openness and wisdom. You rock!
glad you found this post so affirming. i encourage you to check out John’s book, The Church Creative. If you like this post, you will LOVE his book!!!
A creative Father should lead to creative children. It so interesting to see who God “is” based on an individual’s experience with their own father/mother figures. It can range from God the ‘s.o.b.’ to God the loving protector, to God the empowered, who expects us to unleash our gifts on the unsuspecting world on His behalf. I kind of like the third choice, which to me, reflects the creator God. After all, everyday, we swim in a real universe created from what He dreamed up for us!
Hi Al,
Amen and amen and AMEN! Totally love this, what you are saying here. The Creator created Creatives in that we are all Creatives. Yes! I think so to and love how you framed it here.
Thanks for reading and stopping by…and hey, I have not seen you and Dorothy forever. Hoping our paths cross soon!
spot on observations and insights…strikes a nerve in the best possible way. I concur with the above comment when it comes to labels but labels & people appear to be a habit.. we’re funny like that. Regardless, count me in.
My brother Ron,
Thanks for reading and jumping into the convo. I hear ya on the labels thing. Glad the creative part is resonating with you. Somehow I’m not surprised!!!
Prior to now, I’d been serving in church with my creative gifts since I was 13. Strangely, church seemed quite greedy with my expressions, limiting them to self-referencing, “body”-focused activities which edified or entertained the church itself. I could lead the worship, write its songs, teach its drama team or make banners for the church, but my creativity was never called upon to help the church expand its boundaries or explore new ways of doing things. If your “talents” can be harnessed and your wandering, exploring mind kept on the narrow path of mimicking the latest worship “sound”, or designing hip graphics for the church songwriter, all is well. However, the church has little use for the dreamer, the boundary pusher, the wanderer and the questioner, despite the fact creativity calls for all of these subversive acts, and more besides. To be creative is to think freely, to find new ways of doing things, but I have found the attitude of the church toward true creativity to be reflected in this sign I once saw outside a church — “A free thinker is Satans slave.” The church’s insistence my art and my heart were only ever “good” if I were leading worship or fitting sone other predetermined role or function is part of the reason I left the church. The method and the culture of all the churches I’ve ever been to was decided behind closed doors by white, middle aged, middle class, church professionals, in the fashion of good business and proven marketing techniques, well before the actual church ever were askec gor their input. I grew tired of my creativity only bring called on in consultation about what colour we should paint the feature wall in the dull, empty-for-six-and-half-days-a-week church space, instead of us talking about ways we could use that space other days to serve our community. I grew tired of singing and writing for fat, well-fed, jaded, over entertained Christians, when what i really wanted to do was reach the hurting ones amongst them and tell them “me too”. I wanted to find new ways to seek out and love the lost and hurting, instead of being told my “talents” would be virtually buried if I used them anywhere else but in church on Sundays.
Good on you Pam for opening another can of worms.
@Jo,
damn, girl. That is some good writing. Hope a blog post is born for you on this. You have a deep cave of treasure to mine in there for the rest of us.
Yes, creativity can be exploited and i’m sorry though not surprised to hear that this was your experience since you were a young teen. Ugh. Ugh. Ugh. Reminds me a children’s pastor I used to know.A very talented musician and teacher, he offered low cost music lessons for kids. I was thrilled as we are a musical family. I got my 11 year old daughter signed up to begin keyboard.…. no learning how to read music or scales or anything like that. Learning worship songs in order to be recruited to play on the kids worship team for kids church. At first this all sounded so good. She learned her three songs and got to play on the worship team within months.
And then she got bored. She wanted to LEARN how to play keyboard and not just learn to peck some songs out for Sunday morning. Her interest in music waned after than until she began high school and picked up guitar. I regret that I did not get her a “regular” keyboard instructor when she was younger, but thank God I did for guitar! (she now also plays ukelele…you’d love my Rose…she has that total hippy/hipsterish vibe going on!)
I am aghast at the blatant oppressive nature of what you saw on a church sign:
“A free thinker is Satans slave.” </b
For real? Oh Lord! Jesus was in many ways a Free Thinker…in fact he was the epitome of a free thinker!
Thanks for chiming in Jo. Let me know if you blog on this! (which, btw, I tried to subscribe to your blog but the Rss link was broken. )
I think the best places are those that make the most of everyone’s gifts, and don’t assume anyone’s gifts are worth more than anyone else’s. That way different people, with different personalities, can be served, and have their needs met, in the non-believing community. At the same time, people’s individual personalities can be fulfilled in the use of their gifts. This is truly the one body made of different parts. One must not overlook another, or promote oneself and one’s own gifts above those of another. We must all serve.
I am creative, but I don’t want a label. No labels! I just want to be me, and fulfill all that God has made me to be. I’m wondering if I am called to… can’t quite say it in public yet. Even on a blog lol.
Good post ;-)
Zoe! I totally get what you mean about labels. I don’t like them either. And of course everyone is Creative in one way or another, though obviously some more than others. Labels and roles can be so limiting to the width and breadth of who we each are. I am with you on No Labels! It is perhaps better said that the Creative Spirit that has long been stifled in men and women of faith needs to be turned loose. We need our collective What If factor amped up!
Thanks for your thoughts!
LOVE this Pam!!! As a former creative arts pastor of a mega-church and now Executive Director of a performing arts program and professional dance company, I am standing, applauding and saying BRAVO!! to the thoughts expressed here. In many ways, the arts are perhaps a better vehicle for introducing the kingdom spirit in our post-modern society than the church itself. I have seen this personally over and over again, as audiences are moved to tears by both my students and professional dance company and this then leads to genuine, soulful conversations about spirituality.
Loralee, thanks so much for your comment, especially considering your vantage point as a creative arts pastor! I hope you’ll check out John’s book. I heard a prophetic word years ago that said, The next move of God will be through art.
Hope it is!!! (though I’ll take any move of God anyway God wants it!! LOL)
Pingback: Pam Hogeweide – “what if”