You Might be an Oppressed Chris­t­ian Woman If …

Col­lage art by Me!

I get emails week after week from women who have read my book, Unla­dy­like: Resist­ing the Injus­tice of Inequal­ity in the Church. They tell me their sto­ries of how they are unrav­el­ing their iden­tity from the grip of patri­ar­chal Chris­tian­ity — not from Jesus, but from a ver­sion of faith that keeps women in second-​​class status.

There are other women I know who are not com­fort­able that I use the word oppres­sion. It’s a heavy-​​duty word. It kept pop­ping up in the writ­ing process of Unla­dy­like which wor­ried me. Maybe I’m being too harsh? Too dra­matic? Women sold in slav­ery, that’s oppres­sive. But a woman told she can’t preach? Is that oppres­sive, too?

I met up with a group of wise, older women I know. We get together every few months to sort out together the things we are reflect­ing on. We call our­selves the Patina Sis­ters.  At one gath­er­ing at my friend Jane’s house, I threw it out there as we sat around the fire pit in Jane’s gar­den. “Am I going over­board using the word oppres­sion? Is it an overstatement?”

The group lit into con­ver­sa­tion pretty quick. “No, I don’t think so. I felt oppressed when I was told in sem­i­nary I couldn’t be a pas­tor because of my girl parts,” said one woman. “And what is oppres­sion?” she con­tin­ued. “It’s when power is used against some­one to hold them back from being who they are. There are all kinds of acts of oppres­sion. Some are just more obvi­ous than others.”

We talked at length, my Patina Sis­ters and I, about the covert pres­ence of oppres­sion almost invis­i­ble in many churches we were famil­iar with. Such as the many big churches in our area that do so much good that the ban­ning of their women from the pul­pit or posi­tions of spir­i­tual author­ity seems mun­dane in com­par­i­son. It can be quite a mind shift for a woman in a social-​​justice dri­ven church to real­ize that she is being oppressed in her beloved faith tribe

How can a woman know if she is being oppressed or not? In the spirit of come­di­enne Jeff Foxworthy’s famous You Might Be a Red­neck com­edy rou­tine, I want to give you,

You Might Be an Oppressed Chris­t­ian Woman If …

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if women are blocked from pas­toral roles in your church.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you only see men in preach­ing from the pulpit.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if when you want to talk to your pas­tor about a con­cern you have, he asks to see your hus­band instead.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if your church teaches you that God cre­ated you to sub­mit to male leadership.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you think it’s ok that women sub­mit and that God cre­ated you to serve men’s leadership.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you are con­vinced that your life is not ful­filled unless you get mar­ried and have children.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you don’t trust your own opin­ions, but seek val­i­da­tion from male fig­ures to affirm your ideas.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you are con­cerned that you are self-​​centered just because you’d like to teach or preach.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you feel secret shame for want­ing to have more voice in your faith community.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if when you do speak up about equal­ity and are hushed you retreat back into your fem­i­nist closet.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you feel guilty for want­ing equal­ity with men.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you feel like a fail­ure because you are not a sub­mis­sive woman or wife.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you worry that your loud per­son­al­ity is unbe­com­ing for a woman of God.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you dumb your­self down in order to not out­shine the men in your church.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you think the Bible teaches that women are designed to serve male lead­er­ship rather than live as equal partners.

You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if you are read­ing this and think that equal­ity is a hereti­cal doc­trine that is pol­lut­ing the church.

If you think you might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman I hope you’ll do some­thing about it. You don’t have to remain oppressed. There is a holy wind of change gust­ing up across the globe, the church included, where women are being agi­tated to shake off being less than because of their vagi­nas. It is unjust. It is oppres­sive. It is not how Jesus treated women. The way churches treat women today does not match how Jesus treated women.

I hope you’ll pass this on!

What other You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman  would you add to this list?

Did this post res­onate with you? Pass it on!

Comments

You Might be an Oppressed Chris­t­ian Woman If … — 15 Comments

  1. As a guy, my com­ment may need spe­cial “vet­ting” to qual­ify as legit. But I’d offer this one: You know you are an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if male infi­delity is jus­ti­fied as being a wife’s fail­ure (due, of course, to her not “keep­ing her­self up” for him). I’ve heard it, I’ve read it. You ladies decide if it fits.

    • If your com­ment need­ing vet­ting that’d just be oppres­sion in the other direction.

      I am shocked that that has ever been preached. In the UK, most Chris­t­ian ladies (in my expe­ri­ence) are make-​​up free and dressed in what’s prac­ti­cal or com­fort­able, rather than what looks ‘attrac­tive’ or ‘sexy’. Not that the few who do wear make-​​up are right or wrong, or that the comfortably-​​dressed ladies look awful (gra­cious I could dig myself a hole if I wasn’t care­ful). It is the one thing that sets apart Chris­t­ian ladies — they’re more ok with just being them­selves, with­out embell­ish­ment. Some­times the things I’ve heard have been said in the name of the gospel sound more like things you’d expect from the Taliban.

      Doesn’t the Tal­mud say some­thing about a man’s duty to ‘please’ his wife and keep her ‘satisfied’?

      • @Sandy, yeah, in the States we have so much mes­sag­ing on out­ward appear­ance that even the image of a “good chris­t­ian woman” has become informed by the cul­tural pres­sures of flaw­less beauty and then the church adds to it “flaw­less spir­i­tu­al­ity.” Women are born into a cul­ture that shames us and then born again in to church cul­ture that shames us fur­ther. plus, there was an inter­net dust up a while back when a high pro­file min­is­ter fell into sex­ual sin and another high pro­file min­is­ter responded by warn­ing xtian women to “not let them­selves go” or their hus­bands could suc­cumb to temp­ta­tion, too.

        Ick. I kid you not!

        We still have a long ways to go to human­iz­ing Christ fol­low­ing women (and men) as flawed human beings liv­ing under the ban­ner of grace.

        • Ah. I saw some­thing on youtube where that same high pro­file min­is­ter (read about it on another blog) takes one sin­gle bible verse, gives a delib­er­ately par­ti­san read­ing of it, and then pro­ceeds to use it as the rea­son women should not work and men should. If any­one with even a mod­er­ate intel­li­gence knows the verse in con­text, they know it’s noth­ing to do with what he said. It’s like those peo­ple who use the NT for anti­semitism. It makes me angry when peo­ple in posi­tions of author­ity delib­er­ately dis­tort things and it means their motives are other than truth and love. God is love. Any­thing less than love is not God. Here endeth the les­son LOL

          • @sandy, the lens of patri­archy dis­torts EVERYTHING! In his won­der­ful book, The Gen­der Knot, author Alan John­son does a bril­liant job unrav­el­ing the patri­ar­chal trail and show­ing us the deep root­ed­ness of it through­out the cul­tures of the world — Chris­t­ian cul­ture included (unfortuantely).

            The Bible is used to oppress many peo­ple. (know any­one gay for exam­ple?) It is what agi­tates me the most to be a vocal resister. The dis­tor­tion of the benev­o­lent God I trust exists, and the use of our faith’s sacred writ­ings to sup­port oppres­sion of another. This sh*t has got to stop! (par­don my cussing. i get a lit­tle rowdy with my words when i get emo­tional, though i did show some restraint there by no drop­ping the almighty f bomb! LOL)

            Thanks for adding to the dis­cus­sion Sandy…and so good to hear from you in my email box. Loved your story!

    • @jon, of course it does not fit!! This per­spec­tive is straight up from a patri­ar­chal view of women and of mar­riage. It takes the respon­si­bil­ity off the male to con­trol him­self and remain faith­ful and puts it onto the shoul­ders of the female. Totally dysfunctional.

      Peo­ple stray for all kinds of rea­sons. If a wife has gained weight or lost her hair in chemo or become crip­pled from an acci­dent, etc .… shall the hus­band take on a mis­tress? This is archaic and demean­ing to the wife as well as the mar­riage, reduc­ing the woman to mere prop­erty to please her mas­ter. It is unfor­tu­nate that this oppres­sive atti­tude con­tin­ues to thrive in many cul­tures around the world includ­ing huge pock­ets of Chris­ten­dom, the one cul­ture that is meant to be most free­ing for both male and female.

      Thanks for adding this thought, Jon. And the book is on the way!

  2. You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if when you do speak up men are the ones telling you that your wrong, or that they are sorry you views are so far ‘left’. You might be an oppressed woman when you are told that your pas­sion and fight for equal­ity of all is not bib­li­cal because your stance means homo­sex­u­als and women’s repro­duc­tive rights.

    • @Bridget, ugh. So not right that you have to endure this kind of resis­tance to own­ing your con­vic­tions but THANK YOU that you do!! Young women like you are the future and the present and you are help­ing undo the past of the sis­ter­hood with each stand against injus­tice that you insist upon. YES! I will sup­port you any way I can! There is a bet­ter day com­ing. I know it when I meet women like YOU!

  3. Yes, the word oppres­sion is cor­rect. After all, if the same things were said to some­one purely because of their skin colour, that would be oppres­sion. Oppres­sion is like bul­ly­ing, or spousal abuse. It begins with seem­ingly small things, and grad­u­ally grows. It’s the thin end of fas­cism (yes, I mean that).

    I’d add to the list: You might be an oppressed Chris­t­ian woman if your fiancé tells you that you must promise to say ‘obey’ in the wed­ding vows, and pro­ceeds to make sure you know exactly what the ‘bib­li­cal order of mar­riage’ is every day of your mar­ried life, when ‘sub­mis­sion’ becomes an excuse to dom­i­nate and bully.

    I’d also say the thing about ful­fil­ment com­ing through mar­riage and chil­dren is cul­tural, not just a Chris­t­ian thing. We have such non­sen­si­cal ideals for women even through­out sec­u­lar soci­ety — be sexy (and sex­u­ally avail­able), be glam­orous, be flaw­less, be skinny, be a ‘career woman’, be a breast­feed­ing, organically-​​grown ‘yummy mummy’… as a woman, I am expected to be all things to all peo­ple except *who I am*, which in Chris­t­ian terms is ‘who God cre­ated me to be’, unless the Para­ble of the Tal­ents does not apply to women. Deep breath, rant over ;-)

    • @Sandy, great rant!

      So crazy but true about the mar­riage thing. Did that hap­pen to you?

      I had a hard time call­ing it out as oppres­sion. A decade ago I would not have been able to. I would have thought it harsh and judg­men­tal and undeserving.

      WhatI have since dis­cov­ered is that it is far more harsh and dam­ag­ing to keep women mar­gin­al­ized and con­vince them it’s God’s will. Of course this is not on pur­pose, yet the cul­ture of patri­archy that so long ago infested the church to such an extent that it is accepted as nor­mal and healthy and even defended. You and I are the heretics. We are in good com­pany. Jesus was con­sid­ered a heretic as he agi­tated the reli­gious tra­di­tions that dis­torted the image of. God.

      Thanks for your com­ment ! If you haven’t read my book, I invite you to do so. It will agi­tate you some more!

  4. Great list, Pam.

    And when oppres­sion is really reach­ing an addi­tional dan­ger point is when we, Father or Mother, are teach­ing of mod­el­ing any of the above for our daughters!

    We also need to rec­og­nize then “oppres­sion” is some­times more com­fort­able than speak­ing up and we need to think that though as well. Please don’t take that last thought as blam­ing the oppressed for their oppres­sion, I just rec­og­nize it takes courage, action and risk to break from oppression

    We need to be i this together, men and women.

    • @Al, agreed!!! Stay­ing in a famil­iar place – even if that place is squash­ing me down — is eas­ier than break­ing free and fig­ur­ing out where to go from here. It is much eas­ier and less dis­rup­tive to get along rather than ask ques­tions or dis­pute reli­gious sys­tems. Ask­ing ques­tions gets peo­ple riled up. And we like to avoid con­flict, at least I do.

      Thanks for your comment!